Is John Key An American? Will You Help Us Find Out?

By Travellerev in cooperation with Ben Vidgen

An interesting question was raised by a lady who sent me a letter she received from the department of Justice.
Anita Boccino, now and for many years a New Zealander but originally a US citizen wanted an answer to a very simple question and decided to request a freedom of information request to the department of Justice just after the last elections and the response was baffling.
The Question: Does John Key have dual citizenship and is the other citizenship that of the United States?

10710707_10205264761283777_2188401525470637457_n

 

First of all, my knowledge of New Zealand law is limited so I decided to share the information (with permission from Anita whose name I also divulge here with her permission also) with non other than investigative Journalist Ben Vidgen from the Postman.

Ben Vidgen commented as follows:

  • The letter is in contravention with NZ law as the ministry who received the letter is required to forward it to the ministry or person responsible  within the government who is tasked with the task of maintaining the knowledge with regards to the request. In this case that would have been the Ministry for Immigration or John Key himself as the official in Government most likely to have that information.
  • The letter was send out on the 19th day of the 20 day period in which they are required to respond to OIA requests.
    The delay technique which John Key admitted to using today but which has been known to us as investigative Bloggers/Journalists for a long time indicates that they wanted to put as much time as they legally could between the request and the response. John Key stated the government uses this technique if it is deemed in the best interest of the government but in this case it must surely mean in the best interest of John Key himself which begs the question: What is he hiding?
  • The letter was signed by Tania Warburton who is the Acting Chief Legal Council. For those who don’t know that is the office embedded in the ministry of Justice which advises the government in matters legal. Tania Warburton has many skills and has had many positions very close to the epicentre of power. Here is her resumé according to linked:

    Tania Warburton’s Experience

    Acting Chief Legal Counsel

    New Zealand Ministry of Justice

    Government Agency; 1001-5000 employees; Government Administration industry

    January 2014Present (10 months)

    Deputy Chief Legal Counsel

    New Zealand Ministry of Justice

    Government Agency; 1001-5000 employees; Government Administration industry

    April 2013Present (1 year 7 months) Wellington

    Acting Deputy Secretary of the Cabinet

    Cabinet Office, Department of Prime Minister and Cabinet

    October 2012April 2013 (7 months) Wellington

    On secondment from Crown Law

    Crown Counsel

    Crown Law

    Legal Services industry

    June 1999April 2013 (13 years 11 months) Crown Law Office

    Judges Clerk

    High Court

    January 1997May 1999 (2 years 5 months) Wellington

    Worked for Sir Thomas Eichelbaum, Chief Justice

    That is a very powerful lady responding to a very simple OIA request. What is more Anita had been put through to her when she tried to enquire as how to go about the request without telling her what the request would be and Mrs Warburton explained to Anita in detail how to go about it. So what she did was instruct Anita to write to her and she responded with a letter 19 days later while breaking the law with regards to OIA requests depending on Anita’s limited knowledge. She specifically broke the law’s section 13  which reads as follows;

    Assistance:

    It is the duty of every department, Minister of the Crown, and organisation to give reasonable assistance to a person, who—
    (a)wishes to make a request in accordance with section 12; or
    (b)in making a request under section 12, has not made that request in accordance with that section; or
    (c)has not made his request to the appropriate department or Minister of the Crown or organisation or local authority,—
    to make a request in a manner that is in accordance with that section or to direct his request to the appropriate department or Minister of the Crown or organisation or local authority”.

    So her response: “I have no grounds for believing that information is held by another department or minister in its/his or official capacity.” In fact lets zoom in even further “its/his or official capacity”. is disingenuous at a bare minimum but also in contravention of the law with regards to OIA’s.

    Not only that but with this answer she also gives away who she might have approached for an answer if she had followed the law. No less than the Prime Minister, John Key would have been obliged to answer that question honestly if she had followed the law and forwarded the OIA request to him.

Ben Vidgen in his piece details his research in to the right to own property in the US if not a US citizen and there clearly is space for foreigners to own property in the US under certain conditions which for a rich man like John Key can easily be met so owning a place in Hawaii is not necessarily an indication he might be a dual citizen. Please honour the content and not Ben’s writing style. Dyslexia is a horrible affliction and ridiculing him for his writing rather than taking in the content says more about those doing the ridiculing than Ben’s sharp investigative mind!

One word of warning: If John Key has double citizenship he might not be breaking New Zealand law although I would love to hear from someone about this who is in the know but he may very well be breaking US law which states clearly that US citizens are not allowed to serve in or conspire with foreign governments.

I think that Anita raised a valid question. I think the New Zealand population has a right to an answer. If John Key has sworn allegiance to another country we should know. Especially with New Zealand turning into the 51 state of the US at an alarming rate it might very well be us who have to fear betrayal if John Key does have dual citizenship and not the US.

So here is what you can do:

You can write a freedom of information request:

Here is a sample to copy and paste as written by Ben Vidgen:

To the Ministry of Justice (info@justice.govt.nz ),
To the Ministry of Immigration (Street address:15 Stout Street
Wellington 6011 New Zealand).
To Ministry of Internal Affairs (info@dia.govt.nz)

Under the official information Act 1982 (the Act) I seek information as to whether the Prime Minister, the Rt Hon John Key, holds dual US citizenship and Or is a citizen of the United States.

As pursuant to the Act I require this question is answered within twenty working days, in accordance with section 13 of the Act (“to make a request in a manner that is in accordance with that section or to direct his request to the appropriate department or Minister of the Crown or organisation or local authority”)..

Yours Sincerely (name insert).

Here is a letter you can send to the Ombudsman:

To the Ombudsman info@ombudsman.parliament.nz

Dear Mam

In accordance with Ombudsman Act 1975 I seek assistance in the Ministry of Justice’s refusal to answer an Official Information Act made 27 September, by Anita Bocchino, to the Ministry of Justice and replied on October 13 (subsequently released for public dissemination by Anita Bocchino), as follows;

“Dear Ms Bocchhino

Thanks you for your email of 27 September 2014 requesting under the official information Act 1982 (the Act) information about the Prime Minister the Rt Hon John Key. You asked whether Mr Key holds dual US citizenship and is also a citizen of the United States.

I am refusing to answer your question under section 18(g) of the act on the basis that the ministry does not hold this information and we have no grounds for believing that information is held by another department or minister in its/his or official capacity.

Yours Sincerely

Tania Warburton Acting Chief Legal Counsel”.

I believe in accordance with the Electoral Act (Ministry of Internal Affairs), the Immigration Act, the Official Information Act, the reply is in incorrect, misleading and contravene Section 13 of the Official Information Act 1982.

Your assistance in this matter and getting the required ministry or bodies to answer this OIA, in accordance with the Act, would be greatly Appreciated (insert name)

8 thoughts on “Is John Key An American? Will You Help Us Find Out?

  1. Trying not to make lite of this serious process of gaining information about govts elected persons and there in this case being a possible case of dual citizenship by our PM .
    I find the privacy act so perverse in general trying to obtain information on any level with any govt but especially when the nats have been in govt
    the ability to get what you ask unassisted by a lawyer is like bashing your head against the proverbial
    Be sure when you go on the trail of gaining what you think is everyone’s right to have exposed that your battle will be long without the best legal advice you can afford
    A number of times I have seen OIA returned with so much info blacked out and in some cases threats by the govt of consequences if you pursue your requests
    Its like handling a double edged sword with no handle grip, the privacy act that is
    Your going to get hurt no matter what you do

    • All the Crown NZ govt legislation is perverse.
      If a piece of the Crown’s legislation reads well (like the NZBORA) it is never applied or interpreted correctly by the Crown’s courts. Courts that have no concern for the law, fairness or justice they are just interested in protecting the Crown govt.
      Why does it really matter so much if Key is a dual citizen? Hes a bankster, a Muppet, the PM of the Crown NZ govt.
      Being a citizen is stupid. It just removes rights and grants privileges in place of rights to be given or NOT (and to be “subjected” to legislation).

      Here’s a run down summary for how OIA requests really work for important info.
      The govt delays, then doesn’t provide requested information and tells you to talk to the Crown privacy commissioner who does not help get information and then points to the ombudsman who does noting to help but covers up any privacy act breaches or refusal to provide info under the OIA for the Crown.

  2. I’m in Parliament speaking for my submission against TPPA alongside many others. There’s only been one for it today
    I just wondered if they push it through and ratify despite the loud protesting there may be a conflict of interest of the prime minister

    • No conflict of interest as Key is the Crown’s PM.
      If people could only get their heads around the fact John Key does not work for the people of NZ but the Crown’s corporations and banks.
      The Crown NZ govt views the people of NZ as debt slaves, to be told to vote and to be manipulated and distracted by insignificant “problems” and dramas.

      @Katrina The TPPA is not a lawful trust set up and the people of NZ (as the effected party) had no disclosure.Contract law means the TPPA is invalid.But the people of NZ wrongly believe the TPPA is valid agreement and is legal as that is what they have been told -even told this by the controlled opposition.What are the costs of NZ being the administrator of the TPPA? (A Trust not a free trade agreement)

Leave a Reply to Smilin Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s